Skip to main content

JUDGES FOR SALE: Special investigation into top lawmen being lured with big money jobs in Qatar and the UAE ... Lord McGhie has been with Abu Dhabi court for past two years while ALSO sitting in the Court of Session in Edinburgh ... Veteran human rights campaigner Peter Tatchell, cross-party MSPs and Dubai torture victim accuse them of legitimising despotic regimes ...

TOP judges are accused of selling the reputation of Scottish justice by working for Middle East countries with toxic human rights records.

Two judges are on the payroll of the United Arab Emirates (UAE) where domestic violence against women is legal and where regime critics are tortured and jailed without trial.

The most senior is Lord Hope of Craighead — Scotland’s former top judge, a member of the House of Lords and ex-deputy president of the UK Supreme Court.

Our investigation found that Lord McGhie has been registered to sit in the UAE for the past two years while he was also dispensing justice at the Court of Session in Edinburgh.

Veteran human rights campaigner Peter Tatchell said: "It seems highly inappropriate for Scotland's previous top judge and former deputy president of the UK Supreme Court to work for the UAE given its poor human rights record.

“He is giving legitimacy to the UAE's legal system which does not conform to international standards and is accused of suppressing civil liberties and freedom of expression.

In recent years, retired UK judges have been increasingly lured with big paycheques to new civil courts in Qatar and the UAE states of Abu Dhabi and Dubai.

Lord Hope is chief justice of Abu Dhabi Global Market Courts which also employs Lord McGhie and six other male judges from the UK and Commonwealth.

Another former Lord President, Lord Hamilton, sits in a court in Qatar which is accused of backing international terrorism and using migrant slave labour.

Qatar — which can inflict flogging and stoning for ‘crimes’ such as homosexuality and blasphemy — used to employ yet another former Lord President, Lord Cullen.

Also previously on the Qatari International Court and Dispute Resolution Centre payroll was Sir David Edward who used to sit in the Court of Session and the European Court of Justice.

Qatar, which will host the World Cup in 2020, is accused by some countries of supporting ISIS and other terror groups.

Critics say judges harm the reputation of Scotland’s judiciary and justice system by selling themselves to wealthy despots.

Despite not working within either country’s Sharia system of criminal law, campaigners say the judges effectively legitimise widespread human rights abuses.

Senior MSP Alex Neil, a former SNP minister who backs a judicial register of interests, said: “This is not a good advert for Scottish judges or the justice system.

“They should really question the morality of working for some of the most regressive and dictatorial regimes in the world.

“Retired judges are entitled to do what they want but one would have hoped that their consciences would be pricked.

“Any serving judge seeking such employment should certainly be required to get the explicit permission of the Lord President.

“It is not acceptable for serving judges to moonlight in this way. It appears to be driven by greed as they are already very well paid in Scotland.”


Above: Judges in Qatar's commercial court


Lawyer David Haigh of campaign groups Detained in Dubai said: “This is British judges for sale — and they appear happy to be sold. 

“When people realise that fat cat judges are flogging our law for their golden retirements they’ll be appalled. They get paid a fortune. It’s sheer greed.

“They’re selling the reputation of English and Scottish law which is not theirs to sell.”

Haigh was arrested in Dubai in May 2014 after a dispute with his former employers and was held in prison without trial for 14 months.

The former Leeds United chairman claims he was raped and tortured behind bars after being accused of fraud which he denies and has been fighting for justice ever since.

During his five-year ordeal he was unable to personally appear in Dubai International Finance Centre Court and has complained about an English judges who sits there.

Last year Haigh helped to block the UAE’s bid to extradite Edinburgh bus driver Garrett Black.

Edinburgh Sheriff Court heard that breach of trust charges against Black were fabricated after his daughter split from her abusive husband in Dubai and returned to Scotland.

Sheriff Thomas Welsh QC described Haigh as “an honest, intelligent witness who gave his evidence with calm dignity” and who had been “significantly physically and psychologically damaged by his ordeal in the UAE”.

The sheriff accepted Haigh’s detailed testimony of torture and abuse.

In his written findings, he said: “I fully accept he was repeatedly seriously assaulted by Dubai police officers and Tasered while detained at Bur Dubai police station. I accept he was interrogated and forced to sign a document in Arabic the content of which he could not understand.

“Thereafter, I believed the account he gave of squalid, overcrowded and insanitary detention conditions in Bur Dubai police station. I further believe he was sexually assaulted and raped in the car park of that police station during his detention.”

Haigh said: “All these extradition attempts by Dubai are unsuccessful because the UK courts have concluded there is a real risk of torture, abuse, discrimination and unfair trials.

“The United Nations, Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International and the US State Department are of the same view.

“So while UK courts refuse to extradite to the UAE, our judges are happy to sit in their courts.

“For the judges to say they are independent is nonsense. These countries are using judges to give their courts credibility. It’s terrible. I’ve obviously experienced it myself.

“They’re in this ridiculous position where they know full well what’s going on in Dubai but can’t publicly condone or criticise. I find it horrifying that former UK judges can turn a blind eye to what’s going on.

“It’s becoming an issue as our relationship with the Middle East develops, more and more judges are doing this.”

Tatchell believes the UK authorities should bring in rules about overseas appointments

He said: “These judges appear to be using their reputation in Britain and the Commonwealth to secure lucrative appointments in the legal system of a despotic regime.

“They should make a transparent declaration of the remuneration they are receiving. The British judicial authorities should establish a clear set of rules for former judges who take up private work after the end of their judicial career in this country.”

Labour MSP Neil Findlay: “This remarkable – here we see what appears to be sitting and former Scottish judges cashing in on their status working for a regime [UAE] which according to Human Rights Watch is involved in the Saudi coalition attacks on Yemen, has an appalling record on workers’ rights, arbitrarily detains and forcibly disappears individuals who criticise authorities within its borders, legally permits domestic violence and uses the death penalty.

“How can people who make or have made their living upholding the law in the UK defend their involvement, albeit in the commercial courts, of a legal system such as the UAE?”

David Haigh ... former Leeds Utd chairman was tortured in UAE




SIR DAVID EDWARD: OUR WORK IN MIDDLE EAST IS A POSITIVE FORCE

Sir David Edward travelled to Qatar once to take the judicial oath but never sat on any cases and retired at the age of 75.

He said: “I went out there to be sworn in then came back. I suppose if there had been more work I might have been called upon. I had one visit to Qatar which I didn’t like at all. I just don’t like these places.”

Defending the right of Scottish judges to work there, he added: “The purpose of the court was to resolve commercial disputes outside the scope of Sharia law because the ordinary courts in theses countries are Sharia courts.

“There is much misunderstanding about what Sharia is. It’s not all about cutting off hands and so on.

“I don’t think you’re lending weight to the regime. I think it’s better that there should be some form of independent tribunal. It’s a positive force against bad.”


Sir David Edward ... sworn in as Qatari judge but never sat




JAILED WITHOUT TRIAL, TORTURE, SLAVE LABOUR, MARITAL RAPE OKAY AND DEATH PENALTY FOR GAY SEX: INSIDE QATAR AND THE UAE

QATAR and the UAE are guilty of horrific humans rights abuses.

UAE residents who criticism the regime face imprisonment and torture.

Campaigner Ahmed Mansoor was jailed earlier this year over critical tweets and the death penalty applies to those who “undermine national unity or social peace”.

With 88 per cent of the population foreign, many suffer slave conditions. Domestic workers can work 21 hours per day and risk sexual and physical assaults.

Husbands can assault wives, who must “obey” them, and marital rape is not a crime. Gay sex in Abu Dhabi is “unnatural” and can result in 14 years in prison.

The UAE is a member of the Saudi-led coalition in Yemen which has killed nearly 1,000 civilians since 2015.

Nearby Qatar was last year cut off from the UAE, Saudi Arabia and and other Arab states over its alleged support of terrorism, which it denies.

Freedom of expression is severely limited with one government critic jailed for life in 2012.

Around 40 per cent of the country’s two million workers are involved in construction, often for the World Cup.

Hundreds have died in unexplained circumstances while many are enslaved including women forced into prostitution.

In some courts, a female's testimony is worth half a man's and in some female witness are not accepted. Women must obey their husbands.

Gay sex can result in the death penalty while sex outside marriage can result in flogging or the death penalty.

Alcohol consumption is also punishable by flogging and adultery between a Muslim women and non-Muslim men carries the death sentence.

The death sentence also applies to blasphemy and apostasy — the renouncing of Islamic beliefs.

Above: Opinion of David Haigh by Edinburgh Sheriff Thomas Welsh QC ...




SCOTLAND’S SECRET JUDGES: MIDDLE EAST JOBS STRENGTHEN CALLS FOR TRANSPARENCY

OUR revelations abut judges working for rogue regimes have strengthened calls for a judicial register of interests in Scotland.

Legal campaigner Peter Cherbi launched a Holyrood petition six years ago calling for judges and sheriffs to declare financial and family ties.

After winning cross-party backing, the petitions committee formally called on the government and judiciary to create a register.

Cherbi’s petition has already lead to the creation of an online register of cases where judges recused themselves due to conflicts of interest.

But supporters say that people appearing in criminal courts and litigants in civil courts are entitled to transparency to better identify any conflict.

One sheriff had shares in a company hit by a proceeds of crime action while a judge sat on a case where his own son was a lawyer.

Previous Lord President Lord Gill twice snubbed Holyrood request to discuss the petition and was accused of holding parliament in contempt.

He later found time to travel to Qatar in 2014 where he delivered a speech about judicial ethics.

The Judicial Office for Scotland’s active webpage for Lord McGhie makes no mention of his other job in the UAE.

SMP MSP Alex Neil plans said: “If no bill is brought forward by the government, I would intend to do so myself, as there is significant support from other MSPs.”

Former Judicial Complaints Reviewer Moi Ali said: “This is the 21st century, and yet the judiciary in so many respects continues to act like a Victorian institution.


Lord Gill in Qatar with judiciary chief Masoud bin Mohammed Al-Amri




LORD CARLOWAY: NO ANSWERS TO OUR QUESTIONS

WE asked Scotland’s top judge — Lord President Lord Carloway — if he had any concerns about his judges working in the Middle East.

We also asked if there are any rules in place about such appointments and, if not, whether that is something which should now be considered.

Separately, we asked the Judicial Office for Scotland press officers to ask Lord McGhie if he would be willing to comment on his dual role.

No answers were provided but a Judicial Office for Scotland spokesman said: “Judges are independent and when they reach the statutory retirement age they are entitled to return to private practice or take up posts in other jurisdictions if they wish. This falls entirely outwith the ambit of the Scottish judicial system.

“Retired Scottish judges have been appointed to the Abu Dhabi Global Market Courts, an international court which is recognised by financial centres across the world, where they sit alongside judges from England and Wales, Australia and New Zealand, and deal solely with international commercial disputes. 

“Retired Scottish judges may, up to the age of 75, be re-employed to sit in Scotland's Supreme Courts on an ad-hoc basis, to ensure the efficient disposal of business. There are currently no retired judges with an appointment to serve on the bench in Scotland.”


Secret: Scottish judicial website does not mention Lord McGhie's other job in the UAE


version of this report first appeared in the Sunday Mail newspaper on October 7, 2018

Comments

  1. Own Opinion:
    David Haigh by Edinburgh Sheriff Thomas Welsh QC. Lawyer David Haigh of campaign groups Detained in Dubai said: “This is British judges for sale — and they appear happy to be sold.

    “When people realise that fat cat judges are flogging our law for their golden retirements they’ll be appalled. They get paid a fortune. It’s sheer greed.

    “They’re selling the reputation of English and Scottish law which is not theirs to sell.”

    Welsh goes on to say 'lured to Dubai" and somebody welshed on the deal. Is being lured not the same as being in pursuit of sheer greed or other gain? Had Haigh not been a lawyer would the Welsh result have been the same?

    Show me a lawyer who is not interested in 'show me the money' and not up for sale, then maybe I could believe the quoted comments above.

    Who apart from the entrenched legal practice actually believe “They’re selling the reputation of English and Scottish law which is not theirs to sell.” there is a reputation worthy of sale. Is it not already sold by legal aid scrounging for clients and then past solicitor threats to deliberately thwart Human Rights for Cash in disputes over SLAB funding.

    Look in the mirror all and see what it reveals, if the mirror lasts.
    Greedy lawyers cosy up to fat cat judges when it suits them.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Meet Alex Salmond's expensive legal team ... Crowdfunded cash will bankroll Court of Session battle against Nicola Sturgeon's government ... But spare a thought for the two women who made complaints of sexual misconduct against the former First Minister

MUCH has been written about how the #MeToo phenomenon which began in Holywood was confounded in Holyrood with Alex Salmond’s ugly but effective reframing of himself as the victim following allegations of sexual misconduct by two women.
Plenty has also been said about the chutzpah of a wealthy former First Minister passing round an online begging bowl — stuffed with gusto by the blindly loyal — to pay his legal bills.
But so far little is known about the crowdfunded team behind the impending judicial review of how the Scottish Government handled the complaints made against Salmond.
Thanks to other people’s £100,007, he can afford a lot of expensive lawyers. Senior counsel Ronnie Clancy QC will lead in court. At his side will be advocate Duncan Hamilton, a former SNP MSP.
Central to shaping Salmond’s case is the law firm Levy & McRae and its partner David McKie. Those who take an interest in the plots and personalities of Scotland’s legal profession will be familiar with the Glasgow-bas…

For 22 years PC Karen Harper proudly served the public ... But after complaining about bullying she was targeted in a sinister 'black op' ... Karen was innocent but her carer was destroyed ... The brave whistleblower today breaks her silence to accuse Police Scotland of acting like the Mafia ... And she slams the Scottish Government for creating the toxic culture in policing

An innocent police officer claims she was forced from her job after colleagues waged a secret ‘black op’ to fit her up.
Karen Harper, 50, was allegedly bullied over flexible working hours following the death of her mother.
When she complained about a sergeant she says Police Scotland ordered a ‘fishing expedition’ in a sinister bid to criminalise her and trash her reputation.
Whistleblower Karen — cleared of any wrongdoing — today breaks her silence six months after the end of her unblemished 22-year police career through ill health.
She compares Police Scotland’s senior ranks to the Mafia and criticises politicians and regulators for failing to hold them to account.
She said: “These people destroyed my career and stole three years of my life. The biggest issue is the lack of trust.
“Integrity in policing is essential, especially at the very top but these people are protected. It’s like taking on the Mafia.
“This breeds resentment in the ranks and tarnishes the reputation of the majority of …

Police Scotland's former chief constable allegedly told to 'hire a Scot' as his deputy ... Phil Gormley warned there would be 'political problems' if he did not ... The order left him 'deeply troubled' ... But what did PIRC and the SPA do about the discrimination claim? ... SNP government ministers face questions about alleged meddling in policing

FORMER chief constable Phil Gormley was warned there could be ‘political problems’ if a Scottish candidate was not hired as one of his deputies.
The former head of Police Scotland claims that the order came from Andrew Flanagan, then chairman of the Scottish Police Authority (SPA), during a discussion about a vacant post for a deputy chief constable.
During the meeting last September, Gormley was allegedly told ‘there would be major presentational and political problems if either of the two internal (Scottish) candidates were passed over given how this would impact on the proportion of senior officers who were of Scottish national origin’.
In a document seen by The Times newspaper, Gormley said: “He [Flanagan] indicated that Scottish Government were party to these concerns. As a senior officer of English national origin myself, this concerned me. The national origin of any candidate (from within the United Kingdom) should have no bearing on the selection process.
“This issue and the very …

Buried ceramic animals, a condemned 'eco' classroom, rope structure set on fire and a community centre built from junk ... Architect Lee Ivett linked to a series of bizarre projects in some of our poorest communities ... Best selling book Poverty Safari puts spotlight on Scotland's 'poverty industry'

SCOTLAND’S ‘poverty industry’ is under the spotlight thanks to rapper Darren ‘Loki’ McGarvey’s best-selling book Poverty Safari.
McGarvey - raised in Glasgow’s Pollok - criticises well-meaning experts who descend on deprived communities with big ideas about how to fix deep-rooted social problems.
Tapping into public funds, their creative projects make little difference to the people who live there.
Reporter Russell Findlay looks at an architect behind a series of bizarre taxpayer-funded schemes in some of Scotland’s poorest areas.
>>>
LEE Ivett is no ordinary architect. Working from his Glasgow-based studio Baxendale, he is described as an ‘urbanist with a track record of developing transformational long term projects’.
Using edgy but vague buzzwords, one architectural website continues: “His mode of practice is intensely generative, developing low-budget socially-focused projects from scratch largely for marginalised communities within Scotland and beyond as a means of identifying…

Scottish Police Federation boss Calum Steele launched a toxic Twitter tirade in defence of acting Chief Constable Iain Livingstone ... He smeared ex-ACC Angela Wilson by hinting at corruption and branding her a 'buffoon' ... Police Scotland have now upheld Wilson's complaint against Steele ... Here we take a look at the latest scandal to engulf the force and the murky legal games behind the scenes

BEFORE a newspaper publishes a story, attempts are usually made to speak to the various people or organisations involved in order to allow them to respond.
It should be a straightforward, common sense process — but not always.
Sometimes people chose to play games. Lawyers are unleashed.
Take the Two Cal(l)ums — Calum Steele and his legal adviser Callum Anderson.
For the past decade, former Highland bobby PC Steele has enjoyed perks and status as general secretary of the Scottish Police Federation (SPF).
PC Steele often shares the benefit of his wisdom on Twitter.
When the BBC quizzed Police Scotland’s acting Chief Constable Iain Livingstone about allegations of sexually assaulting a junior female colleague at a police college, eyebrows were raised.
Former ACC Angela Wilson publicly questioned whether Livingstone was a suitable person to lead the crisis-stricken national force despite being cleared of the alleged crime.
Steele turned to Twitter where he branded Wilson ‘one of the most incompet…

#SCOTLAND THE FREEBIE ... Los Angeles-based social media influencers enjoy five-star freebie trips to Scotland paid for by taxpayers ... But do Twitter, YouTube and Instagram posts breach ASA and FTC advertising rules?

AMERICAN social media stars were given Government-funded, all expense paid trips to Scotland in exchange for gushing online reviews.
Four online ‘influencers’ were gifted the freebie visits and put up in five-star accommodation across the country.
But the Twitter, Instagram and YouTube posts they published were not marked as advertising, in a likely breach of US Federal Trade Commission laws.
Mary Engle, head of the FTC's advertising practices division, said: "Under FTC law, advertising should be identifiable as advertising, in whatever medium it appears.
"This means a social media post that's a promotional message rather than an independent opinion should be clearly presented as such, for example through a prominent disclosure that it is sponsored advertising.
"We issued guidance for advertisers and endorsers outlining when, why and how they must disclose their relationship so that consumers are not misled into thinking that sponsored posts are independent.”
The Scot…

National Crime Agency officers and MI5 spooks target Costa del Sol kingpin as potential Daniel v Lyons peacemaker … Extraordinary bid to end 17-year drug war being waged across central Scotland .... But factions reject plea to stop tit-for-tat bloodshed

A MAJOR criminal based in Spain has been approached by security services in a desperate bid to end the Daniel v Lyons drugs war.
The wealthy expat, who is in his 60s and was once jailed over a heroin haul in Glasgow, was asked to broker a truce between the warring families.
Both gangs - the most prominent of Scotland's 22 high level organised crime groups - have been told the approach may have come from Britain's domestic security service MI5.
The National Crime Agency (NCA), described as Britain's FBI, is understood to have been involved in the extraordinary move to end Scotland's deadliest criminal feud.
One source said: “The expat criminal was in London on business when he was approached by either the security services or the NCA.
“He was asked to use his influence by relaying the message to both sides that the bloodshed in Scotland had to end.
“Unfortunately, it seems not to have had the desired effect. There has been so much violence that neither side seems willing to b…

Crown Office prosecutors DROP case of £400m collapsed hedge fund boss Gregory King ... The lawyer and three other men were reported to prosecutors after a fraud probe into Heather Capital ... But £28.4m claim against suspended sheriff Peter Watson and some past and present Levy & McRae partners continues

CROWN prosecutors will take no action against four men following a fraud probe into a collapsed £400 million finance firm.
Lawyer Gregory King, 49, and three others were reported to the Crown by detectives who investigated his hedge fund Heather Capital which was based in the Isle of Man.
Heather, launched by King in 2005, attracted investors from around the world and loaned money to fund property deals.
Following its 2010 collapse, Heather’s liquidator Paul Duffy claimed that around £90million was unaccounted for and a police fraud probe resulted in the four men being reported to the Crown Office in April 2013.
An Isle of Man court judgement likened Heather to a ‘Ponzi’ scheme, made famous by US financier Bernie Madoff who was jailed for 150 years in 2009.
The other three reported by police were lawyer Andrew Sobolewski, of Bridge of Weir, Renfrewshire, Andrew Millar, of ­Cambuslang, near Glasgow, and Scott ­Carmichael, of Thorntonhall, near Glasgow.
Last year there was criticism of the Cr…

How did 'superhuman' SNP health minister manage to work 376 days in a year? Quango queen turned MSP Jeane Freeman asked to explain how she took so much taxpayers' cash from the NHS and other public bodies ...

HEALTH secretary Jeane Freeman has been urged to explain her ‘superhuman’ work record after she spent more days on quangos than there are in a year.
The SNP politician has been dubbed Scotland’s ‘quango queen’ due to the large number of posts she held with public bodies before becoming an MSP.
But she now faces questions over how much taxpayers’ money she received in the financial year 2013/14.
Our probe found that she pocketed £57,000 as a member of the Scottish Police Authority which works out at £300 for 190 days.
During the same period, she worked three days per week on the NHS National Waiting Time Centre board in Clydebank whose annual accounts show she received up to £25,000.
She also served between 20 to 30 days with the Judicial Appointments Board for Scotland at a rate of  £295 per day.
If the public records are accurate, they suggest that Freeman spent up to 376 days on the public payroll during that year.
In addition, she also ran her own public affairs consultancy firm Freeman A…